How to start
After delivering the rum, return to Shirley after roughly an in-game day. If you only see her talking to Peggy, come back later and wait for Shirley to call Jason over.
Before you continueStart the return ride while Chapter 1 is still free to explore. Once you begin Tourist Trap, Shirley’s optional chain ends.
Check the house across the water
Follow the road around the water to Peggy’s house. The scooter is in the driveway by the steps, rather than on the main street. Get on it when the interaction prompt appears.

Pull onto Shirley’s porch
Take the scooter back by road. At the destination, let Shirley open the porch door, then ride into the marked space. Stopping on the street leaves the last objective open.

